Algorithmic Bias and Data Privacy in Business Analytics A Framework for Ethical Compliance in Automated Decision Systems
DOI: 10.66838/ma.242
|
Abstract Businesses now use automated decision systems to approve credit, screen applicants, set prices and target offers, and these systems learn from data that carry the history of earlier human decisions and the personal information of the people concerned. Two ethical and legal problems follow: algorithms can reproduce or amplify discrimination, and the data they use can expose individuals. The two problems are usually handled by different teams, with different tools, and sometimes in tension, since measuring bias needs sensitive attributes that privacy rules restrict. This paper proposes a six-stage compliance framework that links scoping and legal mapping, data governance, model development, pre-deployment validation, monitoring and accountability, with decision gates and evidence at each stage. We test several of its controls on a simulated lending process with 30,000 applicants per run and five repetitions, in which historical decisions penalise one group although true repayment is the same in both groups. A model trained on those decisions and given the group attribute amplifies the disparity (disparate impact ratio 0.60, against 0.66 in the historical decisions). Removing the attribute raises the ratio only to 0.73 because a residential proxy predicts group membership with an AUC of 0.84; removing the proxy as well gives 0.79, reweighing 0.81, and group-specific thresholds about 0.98, with unchanged discrimination ability (AUC 0.77) and a modest rise in the default rate among approved applicants for the equal-opportunity variant (17.8% to 19.0%). Privacy tests show that overfitted tree ensembles are vulnerable to membership inference (attack AUC up to 0.86), while regularised models are close to the no-leakage value of 0.5 and generalise better. A differentially private audit, which releases only noisy group counts, estimates the disparate impact ratio almost as accurately as a non-private audit when at least 2,000 decisions are audited, even at a strong privacy setting. The data are synthetic and the legal discussion is general, so the results illustrate the framework and are not legal advice or evidence about any real system.
Keywords
algorithmic bias, data privacy, fairness, automated decision-making, business analytics, compliance, differential privacy, membership inference, algorithmic auditing., |